Halloway was gathering information for a book about forgotten Appalachian communities when he came across a mention of the Dalhart children in a declassified court document. Most of the details were kept secret, but there was enough information to follow the lead. He tracked down former employees of Riverside Manor, obtained partial medical records under the Access to Public Information Act, and eventually found Sarah through a social services database. He wrote to her for six months before she agreed to meet. They met at a restaurant in Charleston, West Virginia, on a chilly November afternoon. Halloway recorded the conversation. The recording, which lasted more than three hours, was never made public, but excerpts were transcribed and published in a limited edition of the article in a little-known historical journal in 2017.
What Sarah had told him that day had completely changed everything he thought he knew about the Dalhart clan. She said the children found in 1968 were not first-generation children. They weren't even
Halloway asked her for an explanation. She explained that the Dalhart children were not individuals, but an extension of the family. When they needed a child, the family performed a ritual. She didn't describe it in detail, but she did mention blood, earth, and what she called "talking," and then a new baby appeared, not born of a mother, not like babies are normally born. They simply came into the world fully formed, integrated with the consciousness of the family. She said that the children shared a single consciousness, a collective mind that allowed them to function as one organism dispersed across multiple bodies. That is why the separation killed them. It wasn't trauma or attachment. It was a rupture, like an amputation of a limb. The body could survive, but the limb could not. And when family consciousness began to fragment in the 1970s, when children began to develop individual identities, it was because the bloodline itself was dying. The rituals stopped. The connection was broken. And without it, children were just bodies, empty shells, trying to understand how to be human without ever learning it.
Sarah told Halloway that it was the last, definitive continuation of a line that had survived for centuries. She said that sometimes she still sensed others, even though they were dead: a deep presence in her mind, voices that were not voices. She said that she had spent most of her life trying to silence them, trying to be just Sarah, a single person, just a human. But it never worked because she wasn't human, not really. It was the last piece of something ancient, something that had remained hidden in the mountains for generations, pretending to be a family, when it was something else entirely. And now, with no way to continue, no way to perform ancient rituals, no way to give birth to the next generation, she was waiting. She waited for the line to finally end. She waited for the last thread to break. She looked at Halloway sitting across the table in the restaurant and said, "When I die, he'll die with me. And maybe that will be for the best."